A writ petition has been filed at the Supreme Court, demanding an end to the practice of rejecting students' research papers and other academic writings or taking action against them solely on the basis of reports generated by software claiming to detect the use of artificial intelligence (AI).
Six law students studying at various institutions affiliated with Tribhuvan University have moved the Supreme Court against the university's practice of rejecting academic work solely on the basis of reports generated by AI detection tools during the evaluation of research papers.
The petition seeks a mandamus order directing the formation of a high-level expert committee to conduct an extensive study and discussion on the actual need, justification, and appropriate use of AI detection technology in the academic sector.
It also seeks an order requiring the formulation of necessary policies and laws governing the use of AI only on the basis of the conclusions and recommendations of the study committee.
The petition further demands a mandamus order prohibiting the rejection or restriction of journal articles and other academic writings solely on the basis of AI detection scores generated by foreign or unverified tools.
It also calls for mandatory human editorial assessment and ensuring that authors are given opportunities for both written and oral hearings before any decision is made.
The petitioners allege that Tribhuvan University and its affiliated institutions have violated the privacy and information rights of students and researchers by uploading their academic work to software operated by foreign private companies such as Turnitin and iThenticate.
They argue that there are no established standards to determine whether such software can reliably detect AI-generated content.
The petitioners have also sought an appropriate court order to immediately halt the use of such software.
The six petitioners are law students Vivek Chaudhary, Roshan Auji, Ashish Keshari, Bikesh Kumar Yadav, Prabhuman Kumar Singh, and Nikesh Nepal.
They have named the Government of Nepal, the Office of the Prime Minister and Council of Ministers, the Ministry of Education, Science and Technology, the Ministry of Defense, Tribhuvan University, and Nepal Law Campus, among others, as defendants.
According to petitioner Auji, the petition was submitted on Friday but has not yet been registered. The Supreme Court will reopen only on Tuesday.